N411FSAero Commander 500-B · 1962

On June 1, 2008, about 1250 Atlantic standard time, an Aero Commander 500-B, N411FS, registered to a private individual and operated by Bevins Air Service, Inc., experienced collapse of the left main landing gear during the landing roll at Cyril E. King Airport (TIST), Charlotte Amalie, U.S.V.I. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time and a visual flight rules (VFR) flight plan was filed for the 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 135 non-scheduled, international, passenger flight from Cane Field (TDCF), Roseau, Dominica. The airplane was substantially damaged and the certificated commercial pilot and six passengers were not injured. The flight originated about 1050, from TDCF.

The pilot stated that after takeoff the flight proceeded to the destination airport and when it was approximately 20 miles from there, the airplane's hydraulic pressure which actuates the landing gear and flaps, began to fluctuate. He lowered the landing gear using the normal gear extension system but the left main landing gear did not go into the down and locked position. He advised the control tower of the situation and attempted to extend the left main landing gear by bouncing the right main landing gear on the runway but was unsuccessful. He departed, and attempted to extend the left main gear using the emergency extension procedure which was also unsuccessful. The flight returned for landing, and during the landing roll, the left main landing gear collapsed.

The National Transportation Safety Board was notified of the accident on July 21, 2008. According to the mechanic who inspected the airplane after the accident, he found a cracked aluminum tube in the left hand nacelle. The tube was cracked beneath the sleeve at the flare for the B-nut which attaches at the inboard side of the left engine nacelle. The tube was supported by one phenolic block about midway along its length. Additionally, all hydraulic fluid was drained from the primary stand pipe reservoir. The tube, P/N 6790246-101, identified as Tube Assembly Hydraulic Pressure, was removed from the airplane and sent to the National Transportation Safety Board (Safety Board's) Materials Laboratory, in Washington, D.C.

Examination of the tube by personnel from the Safety Board's Materials Laboratory revealed that the majority of the crack was perpendicular to the surface and contained faint crack arrest positions consistent with fatigue cracking. Small ratchet marks were noted in the central portion of the crack adjacent to the outside diameter surface, indicating that initiation of the crack was from multiple origin areas at the beginning of the flared end. No evidence of material defects or mechanical damage was noted in the origin area. The flared end of the tube adjacent to the fracture surface showed evidence of use but did not contain large amounts of deformation. The flared end at the opposite end of the tube was out-of-round. Further examination of the tube revealed a circumferential wear area approximately 4 inches from the middle radius of a 90-degree bend near the cracked end of the tube; the wear was consistent of being made by a loose clamp. A second area of wear was noted near the first but on the opposite side of the tube. The tube also exhibited gradual bends that were not consistent with discrete bends associated with a newly manufactured tube.

Personnel from the airplane Type Certificate Data Sheet holder reported that the cracked tube is required to be supported within 6 inches of the tangent point of each bend; therefore, a minimum of two clamps are required. Inspection of the tube for condition is specified in the 100-Hour inspections.

The operator reported that the total time on the tube is the same as the airplane total time, or 18,153.9 hours. Additionally, the mechanic reported the airplane is maintained in accordance with the manufacturer's inspection program, and the last Annual/100-Hour inspection occurred on April 30, 2008. The airplane total time at that time was 18,092.3 hours.