N601XSmith AEROSTAR 601 · 1977

On April 23, 2020, at 2139 mountain daylight time (MDT), an Aerostar 601, N601X, was destroyed when it was involved in an accident near Craig, Colorado. The student pilot sustained fatal injuries. The airplane was operated as a Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 personal flight.

Radar track data indicated that the airplane departed Jersey Shore Airport (P96), Jersey Shore, Pennsylvania, about 0719 mountain daylight time (MDT) and arrived Findlay Airport (FDY), Findlay, Ohio, about 851 DT. The airplane departed FDY about 1337 MDT and arrived at Red Oak Municipal Airport (RDK), Red Oak, Iowa, about 1418 (MDT). Track data indicated the airplane likely departed RDK about 1508 MDT, continuing westbound again, climbed to a maximum cruise altitude of about 9,500 ft then descended and landed at Northern Colorado Regional Airport (FNL), Fort Collins/Loveland, Colorado, about 1949 MDT.

A fixed base operator (FBO) line service technician at FNL stated that he saw the airplane taxi from the runway. He said the airplane's right engine was not running, and the student pilot was trying to start it. The engine did not restart, and the airplane continued to taxi to the ramp. He asked the student pilot if everything was "okay," and the student pilot said, "yeah cut it a little close on fuel." The line service technician said the airplane was leaning "quite a bit" toward the right, which he attributed to a fuel imbalance. The technician said the engines sounded fine except for the student pilot running out of fuel during the after-landing taxi.

The technician at FNL said he looked in the airplane and did not see it equipped with automatic dependent surveillance broadcast (ADS-B) equipment and did not know how the student pilot was going to fly the airplane over the mountains. He said the airplane was equipped with a panel mounted Garmin 430 and a transponder and the airplane did not have a pressurization system. He said he saw an oxygen tank in the airplane and did not know the amount of oxygen present in the tank.

An FBO customer service representative at FNL stated the student pilot told her he purchased the airplane in New York and was "going to try to get over the mountains." The student pilot said he flew on a commercial flight from California on the same day he purchased the airplane. He said he had to go over the mountains and through Utah and was destined to California. The representative said the student pilot was "really tired" and did not have cash to buy Red Bull, so she made him coffee. The student pilot told her that he left New York later than he wanted to because he was talking with the former airplane owner. He told the technician the airplane was his fifth airplane that he owned.

Radar track data indicated the airplane departed FNL about 2037 MDT, turned westbound, and climbed through about 12,000 ft. The airplane made a left, almost 360° turn, and continued to climb throughout the turn before it flew west/southwest and reached about 16,000 ft. The airplane continued west/southwest for a little over 40 miles, climbing again and reaching about 22,000 ft, then turning right about 90° to fly northbound momentarily before turning left and heading west/northwest and descending to about 20,000 ft. The airplane then climbed back to about 22,000 ft, remained there briefly, and then descended to about 20,000 ft. The airplane then turned left to the southwest, then turned southbound, and entered a period of erratic flight climbing to over 23,000 ft., before beginning to a left turning descent. The airplane lost altitude rapidly and was heading in a west/northwest direction before track data was lost at about 2139 MDT.

The student pilot was not in communications with air traffic control while en route from FNL and did not receive an instrument flight rules clearance to operate the flight in class A airspace.

The airplane wreckage was located on April 24, 2020, about 15 miles west of Craig, Colorado.

No pilot logbook records were recovered during the investigation.

The student pilot did not hold a pilot certificate with an appropriate class rating/endorsement for the make and model of the accident airplane. Operations requiring an instrument clearance, such as flight into class A airspace, would have required an instrument rating.

The airplane was severely fragmented, and the wreckage path extended an estimated 300 ft. along a north/south heading in sparsely populated mountainous terrain at an elevation of approximately 10,073 ft.

All components of the airplane were distributed along the wreckage path, which was consistent with a low-angle high-speed impact with terrain. The airplane and ground scarring exhibited a black color consistent with soot.

A green cylindrical tank consistent in color with an oxygen tank was separated from the airframe and was resting along the wreckage path. Portions of pneumatic lines were attached to the tank and exhibited impact damage and separations from impact. Due to accident-related damage, the amount of the tank’s contents prior to the accident are unknown, and the functionality, if any, of the oxygen system is unknown.

The Aeronautical Information Manual defines Class A airspace as that airspace from 1,8000 ft msl up to and including flight level 600, including the airspace overlying the waters within 12 nautical miles off the coast of the 48 contiguous States and Alaska; and designated international airspace beyond 12 nautical miles off the coast of the 48 contiguous States and Alaska within areas of domestic radio navigational signal or ATC radar coverage, and within which domestic procedures are applied.

Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Section 91.225, Automatic Dependent Surveillance Broadcast (ADS-B) Out Equipment and Use, stated in part:

(a) After January 1, 2020, unless otherwise authorized by ATC, no person may operate an aircraft in Class A airspace.